In Search of a Leader
Someone once said “It's hard to lead a cavalry charge if you look funny on a horse”. I’m afraid Saurav Ganguly is starting to look funny on the horse. In the past four years he along with John Wright has transformed the Indian side from meek side lacking self belief to a side that is arguably the second best side in the world. All this good work is in danger of falling apart if he overstays his welcome. With John Wright already making the decision (right one I must add) to move on after this series against Pakistan time is now right for Ganguly to give up the captaincy and bring down the curtain on a glorious partnership of Indian cricket.
The Ganguly and Wright partnership has taken India to the exalted position they are in now, but the job is only half done. To carry India to the next level we need an infusion of fresh ideas. Ganguly’s captaincy lacks it. Moreover his batting though supreme on its day lacks the consistency it needs for test cricket and is keeping talented youngsters out of the team. Assuming Ganguly would quit soon lets look at the options.
The Contenders
Rahul Dravid: The strongest contender for the post. He is at his peak of his skills as a batsman. He is also a model professional who sets a great example for the youngsters in the team. He has also demonstrated admirable nous for the job in every opportunity he has had so far to lead.
Strengths: A Model professional
Weaknesses: Maybe too intense to sustain as a captain
V.V.S.Laxman: Another favorite of the pundit, he is an intelligent thinking cricketer who has the mental ability for the job. As a kid he had a choice of pursuing a career in medicine but chose cricket instead. Many, including me, think the added responsibility of captaincy would bring out the best in him. His current form and his inability to cement a one day berth may count against him.
Strengths: Intelligent and nerveless in tough situations
Weaknesses: His form, fitness and one day position
Virendra Sehwag: The dark horse in the race for captaincy, Sehwag has already been entrusted the captaincy of Delhi and North Zone. Contrary to popular opinion I think he is a thinking cricketer as demonstrated quite so often by his bowling at the death in one day matches. He also has age on his side to grow in the role. One thing that would worry most observers is how captaincy would affect his batting. Surely Sehwag the batsman is too precious to lose to captaincy.
Strengths: His age and his cricketing brain
Weaknesses: Apprehensions about how captaincy would affect his batting
Others: Others options are-
Sachin Tendulkar: Might want one more shot at the job but not a serious long term option
Kaif or Yuvraj: May eventually get the job but need to get a settled place in the test team before that happens.
Conclusion
I think the period after Ganguly’s departure would see Dravid installed as captain. Dravid is a safe option for the selectors and they are bound to go that way. I would have gone with Laxman but it is difficult to argue with the choice of Dravid. The selectors should also look at getting Kaif into the team and entrusting him with the job of vice-captain with a long term view of grooming him as a captain. Sehwag should be left alone to concentrate on what he does best: destroy attacks.